Sierra Club Home Page   Environmental Issues   My Backyard

Search
Explore, Enjoy and Protect the Planet  
Florida Chapter Home
Get Outdoors
Calendar
Groups
Newsletters
Join or Give
Contact Us
sierraclub.org
(photo)


Issue Co-Chair
December McSherry
15212 SW 79 Avenue
Archer, Florida 32618
(352) 495-2997

Issue Co-Chair
Dick Williams
sail@gator.net

Issue Committee Members:
Lee Emerson
Karen Orr
Dick Stokes
William Painter
In This Section
 
Get Involved
Some Conservation Links
Smart energy
Energy
Agriculture
Off-Shore Oil
America's Wild Legacy
Biodiversity
Bone Valley
Coastal and Marine Issues
Everglades
Green Swamp
Sprawl
Manatee
Safe And Healthy Communities
Safe Drinking water
Toxics
Wetlands & water
Democracy & The Environment
Clean Money
Trade
Chapter Site

Issues, Florida Chapter

Agriculture

Sierra Club supports sustainable farming practices for the provision of high quality food and forage. It is the responsibility of the citizens and the government of Florida to protect clean air, clean water and provide wildlife habitat, as they are necessary for production of vital healthy crops and livestock.


Major Trends

Florida is losing cropland at a rate of 246,000 acres per year to urban development. We need to preserve and protect remaining agricultural and rural land in Florida for future generations. This can be done through updating adequate local comprehensive plans to include urban boundary lines and provision of conservation easements

Our natural resources are being quickly sacrificed to the demands of Industrial Agriculture. In some areas of Florida, industrial agriculture is responsible for groundwater pollution, contamination of the aquifer - the sole source of our drinking water, and poisoning of Florida's estuaries; these resources are vital for the our survival and for a thriving economy.

The Florida legislature has refused to act in the past to prevent air and water pollution from agricultural sources that damage the environment and threaten the health of Florida's citizens. Our state legislators have rendered our local governments powerless to protect our citizens and natural resources.

Industrial Agriculture has added a toxic cocktail of nutrients to Florida Bay and the Gulf of Mexico leading to massive fish kills and diseases plaguing the coral reefs in the Florida Keys. Green algae laden water has replaced clear healthy water. Coastal waters are so sick that reported deaths of manatees and dolphins, fish and bird kills and diseases affecting sea turtles have risen dramatically. Deadly Red tide events are occurring more often.

Aquatic life, sea grasses and Coral Reefs require clear, clean, nutrient-free waters to thrive.


Threats

Industrial agriculture has now polluted the Suwannee River Basin worse than Lake Okeechobee.

Almost a million acres of sugar cane is grown in the Everglades Agricultural Area south of Lake Okeechobee. Fifty years ago the Army Corps of Engineers drained 700,000 acres in the heart of the Everglades at the headwaters of the River of Grass. The Everglades are being poisoned by the pollution-laden water pumped off those sugar cane fields. The polluted runoff makes its way through the Shark River Slough into Florida Bay and the Gulf of Mexico.

The amount of nitrogen flowing with runoff into the Florida Bay went from roughly 750 tons in 1981 to more than 2,500 tons in 1982, according to statistics from South Florida Water Management District. The numbers skyrocketed in the 1990's and peaked in 1995 to almost 5,000 tons. Jeb Bush's administration recently gave Big Sugar phosphorous pollution extensions for another 10 years adding more harm to the ecosystem.

In recent years, hundreds of mega-dairies and industrial poultry producers have located over the high recharge area of the Floridan aquifer in the Suwannee River Basin of North Central Florida. The Suwannee River Basin has become an open sewer for Big Agribusiness. The unique Springs that dot the Suwannee River are now polluted with high levels of nitrates and have turned green with suffocating algal growth. Water quality ratings have radically declined as a result of the untreated raw sewage being produced. Over 3,000 tons of nitrate-nitrogen and 750 tons of phosphorous are transported down the Suwannee River annually to the Gulf of Mexico.

The productive Suwannee estuary is extremely threatened. The crabbers, clammers and fishermen depend on healthy waters in the estuary. This nitrate pollution has resulted in unnaturally high levels of harmful algae that consume oxygen needed by fish and other marine animals. Algal blooms are in part responsible for massive die-offs of sponges and grass beds in Florida Bay. Harmful algal blooms (HABS) cause shellfish and tropical fish poisonings, wildlife mortalities and respiratory irritation and neurocognitive disease in humans.

Human health and wildlife health is linked with ecological disturbances.

The Department of Health has reported increased levels of nitrates and fecal coliform contamination in North Florida wells, as well as at coastal beaches. There have been over 260 beach closures this year and the state is now providing bottled water to two N. Florida counties. This type of contamination can cause illness and diseases such as hepatitis, typhoid, cholera, dysentery and gastroenteritis. Pfiesteria-like organisms found in the rivers cause lesions in fish and are blamed for fish kills in South Florida. They may become more numerous as sewage and fertilizer-laced stormwater fill Florida rivers with chemical nutrients.

Satellite imagery has shown this years blackwater water mass event in Florida Bay to be larger than 1,000 square miles. A Karenia brevis bloom resulted in the Florida manatee die-off. Red tides, chiefly dinoflagellate blooms, have led to the morbidity and mortality of many species. Exposure to toxins occurs through ingestion of cells (e.g., by filter feeders such as sponges, molluscs) (Reinisch et al. 1984) bioaccumulation by consumption of contaminated prey (by molluscs, crustaceans, gastropods, fish, birds, turtles, marine mammals and humans. Cyanobacteria biotoxins can cause tumors (Falconer and Humpage 1996) and have been implicated in chronic diseases of freshwater and estuarine animals. Toxic benthic dinoflagellates (Prorocentrum spp.) can also produce tumor-promoting agents, like okadaic acid, that has been found within the fibroid tissue of dead green sea turtles.


Concerns

Under Chapter 823.14 of the Florida Right to Farm Act (George Kirkpatrick amendment 1997) a corporation has the right to establish a factory farm operation and may situate 1 million chickens, 4,000 cows and 10,000 pigs on property in an aquifer recharge area, next door to a 1st magnitude Spring, a school, hospital, or church, anywhere in the state of Florida. Since this amendment was added, pollution has become rampant in Florida. This amendment has brought about a breakdown in local planning, community protection and the regulation of potential nuisances or pollution.

  • The Florida legislature has given large corporate industrial Agribusiness factory farms the right to pollute in Florida.
  • Local government have been stripped of their right to oppose siting of a factory farm that will pollute the air and water with dangerous chemicals and raw sewage.
  • Vital natural resources of the state, the health and welfare of the citizens have no legal protection with the amended chapter 823.14 of the Right To Farm Act.
  • Local governments may not adopt any rules or ordinances which restrict or limit a bona fide farming activity that is conducted on agricultural lands in accordance with implemented best-management practices. This language was intended to pre-empt virtually all local efforts to impose safety or other standards on farming activities within their jurisdictions
  • "Mad Cow Disease," or Bovine spongiform encephalopathy, (BSE) is a disease that is untreatable, incurable, and ultimately fatal. It may spread if body parts, such as brains, spinal cords, and spleens, body fluids or waste material from animals are fed to ruminants such as cows, sheep or pigs. The Sierra Club Agriculture Committee opposes the inclusion of any body parts, body fluids, or waste material from any diseased animal or undiseased animal in food or feedstuffs for any creature. Even though the U.S.Food and Drug Administration banned this activity in 1997, The Department of Agriculture must step up inspections of feedlots and mills that provide feed.
  • Sewage sludge spread on farms cause health problems and water pollution.

Legislation

Ask state legislators to:

  • Repeal Chapter 823.14 of the Florida Right to Farm Act (George Kirkpatrick amendment 1997) found in the Florida Agricultural Protection Act FLORIDA STATUTES TITLE XLVI. CRIMES CHAPTER 823. PUBLIC NUISANCES
  • Restore the rights of local government to protect the health and welfare of the citizens. A local government or public official should be able to stop the polluter from continuing the polluting activity on behalf of the public-at-large.
  • Bring back "Polluter Pays" public policy and "strict liability" for use of dangerous chemicals to deter possible risk-taking practices.
  • Regulate dairies, large animal confining units (CAFO's) and poultry producers; these are one of the greatest sources of nitrate and phosphorous pollution in Florida.
  • Prohibit transfer of water, water bottling plants, deep well injection of hazardous waste and treated sewage and Aquifer Storage Recovery (ASR's) so there will be clean available water for agriculture needs in the future.
  • Protect and restore wetlands - our greatest water storage area and wildlife habitat in Florida. Oppose wetland mitigation and wetland banking.
  • Prohibit Cypress timber sales for timber and mulch. Cypress swamps are the greatest natural resource in Florida for migratory birds, wildlife habitat, water quality and water quantity.

  • Get the Department of Agriculture to quarantine imported bees to prevent further losses from hive beetle infestation. Florida beekeepers have suffered major losses from a small hive beetle, Aethina tumida.
  • Monitor and control sludge spreading on farms

Websites of Interest

Friends of the Everglades
Farm Bill Conservation Programs
Florida Certified Organic Farmers
Florida Dept of Agriculture and Consumer Affairs
Meet State Agriculture Commissioner Charles Bronson
Blackwater Event Florida Bay
Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
The Capitol
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0810
Phone: (850) 488-3022
Office of Cabinet Affairs Phone: (850) 488-9786


Up to Top